Amish Chicken Thighs

Amish chicken thighs are a hearty, flavorful dish that embodies the simplicity and comfort of traditional Amish cooking. Slow-cooked in a blend of rich spices, butter, and a creamy sauce, this dish results in incredibly tender, juicy chicken with a deep, savory flavor. The Amish are known for their homestyle, wholesome meals made with simple ingredients, and this recipe is no exception.

What sets this dish apart is the way the chicken is cooked. The combination of butter, garlic, paprika, and a touch of cream creates a luscious, melt-in-your-mouth texture with a perfectly golden-brown finish. Unlike fried or heavily seasoned chicken, Amish chicken thighs focus on rich, natural flavors that develop through slow, gentle cooking. Whether served with mashed potatoes, roasted vegetables, or fresh baked bread, this dish is a satisfying meal that’s perfect for family dinners or special occasions.

Why You’ll Love These Amish Chicken Thighs

• Rich and flavorful – The slow-cooked butter and spice combination creates deep, comforting flavors.

• Easy to make – Simple ingredients and minimal effort make this a great weeknight meal.

• Juicy and tender – Bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs stay moist and full of flavor.

• Perfect for meal prep – The leftovers taste even better the next day.

• One-pan meal – Everything cooks in a single skillet for easy cleanup.

• Versatile serving options – Pair with rice, potatoes, or vegetables for a complete meal.

• Traditional homestyle cooking – Classic, wholesome Amish flavors with a creamy, buttery sauce.

• Budget-friendly – Uses affordable ingredients while delivering gourmet taste.

Preparation Time and Yield

• Prep Time: 10 minutes

• Cook Time: 45 minutes

• Total Time: 55 minutes

• Yield: 4 servings

Nutritional Information (Per Serving)

• Calories: 420

• Carbohydrates: 5g

• Protein: 35g

• Fat: 28g

• Fiber: 1g

• Sugar: 1g

Ingredients for Amish Chicken Thighs

• 4 bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs

• 2 tablespoons butter

• 1 tablespoon olive oil

• 1 teaspoon salt

• ½ teaspoon black pepper

• 1 teaspoon paprika

• 1 teaspoon garlic powder

• ½ teaspoon onion powder

• ½ teaspoon dried thyme

• ½ teaspoon dried parsley

• 1 cup chicken broth

• ½ cup heavy cream

• 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard (optional)

• 1 teaspoon cornstarch (optional, for thickening)

Step-by-Step Instructions for Amish Chicken Thighs

Step 1: Season the Chicken

Pat the chicken thighs dry with paper towels. In a small bowl, mix together the salt, black pepper, paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, thyme, and parsley. Rub the seasoning mixture all over the chicken thighs, ensuring they are well coated.

Step 2: Sear the Chicken

In a large skillet or Dutch oven, heat the butter and olive oil over medium heat. Place the chicken thighs skin-side down and sear for 5-6 minutes until the skin is golden and crispy. Flip and cook for another 4 minutes, then remove the chicken from the pan and set aside.

Step 3: Make the Sauce

In the same pan, pour in the chicken broth and scrape up any browned bits from the bottom. Stir in the heavy cream and Dijon mustard (if using). For a thicker sauce, dissolve 1 teaspoon of cornstarch in a little water and stir it into the mixture.

Step 4: Simmer the Chicken

Return the chicken thighs to the pan, skin-side up. Reduce the heat to low, cover, and simmer for 30 minutes until the chicken is fully cooked and tender.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy

Remove the chicken from the heat and let it rest for a few minutes. Serve hot with mashed potatoes, rice, or roasted vegetables, spooning the creamy sauce over the top.

Ingredient Background

Amish chicken thighs are all about simplicity, relying on high-quality ingredients and slow cooking to bring out deep, comforting flavors. The Amish have a long tradition of using fresh, wholesome ingredients, and this dish is a perfect example of their rustic, homestyle approach to cooking.

Chicken Thighs: The Star of the Dish

Chicken thighs are the ideal cut for this recipe because they remain juicy and tender even after prolonged cooking. Bone-in, skin-on thighs provide the best flavor, as the skin crisps up beautifully during searing while the bone helps retain moisture. Unlike chicken breasts, which can dry out quickly, thighs are naturally rich in fat, giving them a succulent texture that pairs perfectly with the creamy sauce.

Butter and Olive Oil: A Flavorful Base

The combination of butter and olive oil provides the perfect foundation for cooking the chicken. Butter adds a rich, slightly nutty flavor, while olive oil prevents it from burning at high temperatures. This duo creates the golden-brown sear on the chicken skin, locking in moisture and enhancing the overall taste.

Creamy Sauce: The Secret to Amish-Style Comfort

The sauce in this recipe is a classic example of Amish cooking—simple but deeply flavorful. Chicken broth provides a rich base, while heavy cream adds velvety smoothness. A touch of Dijon mustard brings a mild tang that enhances the natural savoriness of the dish. The optional cornstarch helps thicken the sauce, creating a luscious consistency that coats the chicken beautifully.

Herbs and Spices: Simple Yet Effective

Paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, thyme, and parsley work together to enhance the flavor without overpowering the dish. Paprika gives a subtle smoky sweetness, while garlic and onion powder add depth. Thyme and parsley provide an earthy freshness, bringing balance to the richness of the butter and cream.

Technique Tips for Amish Chicken Thighs

1. Pat the Chicken Dry for Crispy Skin

Before seasoning, always pat the chicken thighs dry with paper towels. Removing excess moisture helps the skin crisp up beautifully when searing, rather than steaming in the pan.

2. Sear Over Medium Heat for the Perfect Crust

Cooking the chicken over medium heat allows the skin to become golden brown and crispy without burning. Searing also creates flavorful browned bits (fond) in the pan, which later enrich the sauce when deglazed with broth.

3. Don’t Skip the Deglazing Step

After removing the chicken from the pan, add the chicken broth and scrape up the browned bits with a wooden spoon. These bits are packed with flavor and will give the sauce a deeper, more complex taste.

4. Simmer Low and Slow for Ultimate Tenderness

Once the chicken is returned to the pan, cover it and let it simmer gently. This slow cooking process allows the flavors to meld while keeping the meat incredibly tender and juicy.

5. Adjust Sauce Thickness to Your Liking

For a thicker sauce, whisk in a cornstarch slurry (1 teaspoon cornstarch mixed with 2 teaspoons of water) during the final minutes of cooking. For a thinner sauce, simply let it simmer uncovered for a few extra minutes.

Alternative Presentation Ideas

1. Amish Chicken Thighs with Roasted Vegetables

Instead of serving the chicken over mashed potatoes or rice, pair it with roasted root vegetables like carrots, parsnips, and potatoes. The caramelized sweetness of the vegetables balances the rich, creamy sauce beautifully.

2. Amish Chicken Over Homemade Noodles

For a truly traditional Amish experience, serve the chicken over homemade egg noodles. The creamy sauce soaks into the noodles, creating a dish reminiscent of Amish chicken and dumplings.

3. Rustic Skillet Amish Chicken

For a one-pan meal, add halved baby potatoes and green beans directly into the skillet during the final 20 minutes of simmering. The vegetables will absorb the flavorful broth while cooking, making this a hearty and complete dish.

4. Baked Amish Chicken Casserole

Shred the cooked chicken and mix it with the creamy sauce, then layer it in a baking dish with cooked pasta or rice. Top with shredded cheese and bake until bubbly and golden for an easy Amish-inspired casserole.

Freezing and Storing Amish Chicken Thighs

Storing in the Refrigerator

Allow the chicken to cool completely before transferring it to an airtight container. It can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. When reheating, warm it gently on the stove over low heat or in the microwave, adding a splash of broth or cream to loosen the sauce if needed.

Freezing for Later Use

To freeze, place the cooked chicken and sauce in a freezer-safe container, ensuring it is tightly sealed. Freeze for up to 3 months. To reheat, thaw in the refrigerator overnight, then warm on the stovetop over medium heat. Adding a little extra broth or cream helps restore the sauce’s smooth texture.

Prepping Ahead for Easy Cooking

If you want to make this dish ahead of time, season and sear the chicken in advance. Store it in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours, then continue with the sauce and simmering steps when ready to serve.

Healthier Twist Ideas

1. Lighten Up the Sauce

For a lower-calorie version, replace the heavy cream with half-and-half or whole milk. Greek yogurt or a blend of milk and cornstarch can also be used for a creamy texture with less fat.

2. Use Skinless Chicken Thighs

For a leaner option, use skinless bone-in chicken thighs. You’ll still get the rich flavor from the bones while reducing overall fat.

3. Reduce Butter and Use Olive Oil

Cut back on butter and increase the olive oil for a heart-healthier cooking fat without sacrificing flavor.

4. Add More Vegetables

Incorporate mushrooms, bell peppers, or spinach into the sauce for added nutrients and texture. These ingredients absorb the delicious Amish-style flavors while boosting the dish’s nutritional value.

Serving Suggestions for Events

1. Cozy Family Dinner

Serve Amish chicken thighs with creamy mashed potatoes and steamed green beans for a comforting meal that the whole family will love.

2. Holiday Gathering

For a special occasion, pair this dish with homemade dinner rolls and a side of glazed carrots. The creamy sauce and rich flavors make it an excellent choice for a festive feast.

3. Potluck Favorite

Prepare the chicken in advance and serve it in a slow cooker on low heat to keep it warm. Guests can spoon it over rice or pasta for an easy, self-serve potluck dish.

4. Romantic Date Night

Pair Amish chicken thighs with a glass of white wine and a side of roasted garlic asparagus for a restaurant-quality meal at home.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Can I use boneless chicken thighs?

Yes! Boneless thighs cook slightly faster, so reduce the simmering time to 20-25 minutes.

2. What can I use instead of heavy cream?

Half-and-half, whole milk, or Greek yogurt are good alternatives for a lighter version.

3. How do I make this in the slow cooker?

Sear the chicken first, then place it in a slow cooker with the broth and seasonings. Cook on low for 4-5 hours. Add the cream in the last 30 minutes.

4. Can I add potatoes to the dish?

Absolutely! Add diced potatoes to the pan when you add the chicken back in for a complete one-pan meal.

5. Can I make this dish spicy?

Yes! Add a pinch of red pepper flakes or cayenne for extra heat.

Conclusion

Amish chicken thighs are the perfect balance of rich, creamy flavors and tender, juicy chicken. With simple ingredients and easy preparation, this homestyle dish delivers a comforting, satisfying meal that the whole family will love. Whether served over mashed potatoes, noodles, or vegetables, the creamy sauce ties everything together beautifully. Try this timeless recipe for a cozy dinner, a special gathering, or just a hearty meal that brings warmth and tradition to your table.

Print